Dear State Attorneys General: You Failed America. Yes, You.
By Abigail Caplovitz Field | February 28, 2012
Update: My original headline said “Sold Out” where it now says failed. I think it’s more accurate.
Dear State Attorneys General:
Rumor has it that this week we will learn precisely how you failed us all regarding the criminal enterprise that is mortgage servicing and foreclosure in America. That is, rumor has it that more than two weeks after you announced a deal with five bailed-out banks, we’ll all get to see the deal. Well, precisely speaking, we’ll all see the court filing containing the settlement.
Why the Secrecy?
Why aren’t you releasing the deal before filing it? I realize that you’re not officially rulemaking regulators who must seek public comment before finalizing rules. But much of your agreement functions like a regulator’s rule making. So why wouldn’t you, as a matter of good public policy practice, make the deal public for comment before seeking to finalize it with the judge?
Were you worried that insightful discussion of your crappy deal’s terms would end the deal’s perceived political utility? We critics can do that anyway, after it’s filed. Thing is, changing its politics is all we can do at that point. If given the chance earlier we could’ve forced you back to the bargaining table, which might have been productive. In fact, had you been talking to informed critics all along the way perhaps you would’ve cut a different deal to begin with.
By bypassing the public and going directly to the judicial validator, you’re pulling a Bank of New York and Bank of America. BoNY-BofA cut an outrageous deal to BofA’s huge advantage, at the expense of the investors that BoNY supposedly represents. To get that deal blessed they’re using a special state court procedure that has a real chance of working for them. That’s because it’s designed to bless Trustees’ actions without looking too closely at what they are, (and in this case) screwing investors. Similarly, you want the judge to bless your deal without the public looking too closely at it first, screwing the public.
AG Schneiderman, you know the case I’m talking about. You intervened in it because you said the deal was so lousy.
Don’t blame anyone else for your decisions.
Rumor also has it that some of you are feeling over-harshly judged. You fought the good fight; you worked very long hours; you didn’t get paid, and the banks’ attorneys did. You did great work, you say, because hey, these servicing standards are great. (Yes, well, they’re only as great as the enforcement is, and I’ve my doubts about that.)
I’ll give you this: the Feds worked against those of you interested in real justice for the American people. The f*cking Justice Department should have been pouring resources into investigations and indicting people all over the place. The Justice Department needed to go S&L on these guys, just ramped up for scale. I mean, we used 1,000 FBI and dozens of prosecutors to prosecute the much smaller Savings and Loan Fraud. Heck, we used 100 FBI on Enron. The warmed-over Financial Fraud Enforcement Task Force subcommittee (no it’s not new) has 55 investigators. No, President Obama, 55 investigators is not enough.
The SEC, OCC and Fed should’ve been on a law-enforcing and regulating rampage too. If you’d had Feds like those to work with, well, watch out. We might have cleaned house and put people back in the center of public policymaking, not banks and the bankers that run them.
Of course, if the Justice Department or the SEC were disposed to act that way then things would never have gotten this bad. And it wasn’t just federal law enforcement that let you down. Federal law makers did too, under both Republican and Democratic regimes. If Congress hadn’t done the industry’s bidding regarding derivatives, and hadn’t let banks become hedge funds, the crisis wouldn’t have happened. If the OCC, the FTC and the Fed had all been real regulators and enforcers, the crisis wouldn’t have happened.
So state AGs, I give you the slack you are entitled for being saddled with feds who don’t want to do a good deal. And I accept that some or even many of the AGs and their AAGs worked very hard. Are still working very hard. I’ll give credit for that too.
But I can’t give a pass for caving. The stakes are just too high, precisely because the Federal Government has chosen to stand with the banks instead of the people. The people of their States and our nation as a whole needed our AGs to tell the Feds to go f*ck themselves or their banker buddies.
We Need Leaders Who Will Fight For Us
There are times you just have to tough it out and do the right thing regardless of the personal cost. Our soldiers have faced that challenge for a decade, in the face of more trauma and stress than you’ll ever likely know, especially those of our veterans who have served multiple tours. We need soldier-level loyalty from our Attorneys General right now, because who else is there on the side of truth, justice, and the American Way? I mean, that’s as cheesy as can be, but it’s not hyperbole or metaphorical.
The people who orchestrated and facilitated the greatest white collar crime spree ever–a gold-collar crime spree–walk around certain that they will not only avoid jail, but that they can manage the situation to their advantage. They are so confident they are above the law, they don’t hesitate to manufacture evidence to ensure they win their litigation. You know this, because you understand that is what robosigning is all about.
We have a President who styles himself a defender of the 99%, particularly at election time, when his every key policy choice has favored the banks. This push the AGs to take a lousy but superficially pretty deal for the cameras, profoundly weakening them before the terms of the deal are finalized, is just par for the course. If you have any doubt about how power is being wielded, consider the treatment of second liens, and what a rejection of basic commercial and contract principles that it represents in the name of protecting the banks from the consequences of their insolvency.
Think about enforceablity, about how the banks get to manage the info flow–er “report” on their compliance–even though the crimes of at issue are forgery and fraud. Of all people, you know those are crimes of “moral turpitude” which can be used to impeach a witness‘s credibility. They systematically produced evidence for impeachment and you’re letting them testify on their own compliance when they have every incentive to say no problems exist, while maintaining the status quo?
Think about the banks’ insincerity: analysts predict foreclosures will increase in the near term. How can they increase if the banks are complying with the terms of the settlement? Not only would some foreclosures get modified instead, but some or even many would be unprosecutable because of securitization fail. Moreover, all the document processing systems in place have to be totally overhauled. We’re talking about a radical realignment of resources, serious hiring and training. That can’t happen fast enough for one of the first consequences of a deal to increase and speed foreclosures.
If the AGs don’t stand up to the Feds and the banks and refuse to take a bad deal, where is the public supposed to find our champion(s)?
I know the mantra is just wait, the good stuff comes next. But what set of facts can we point to that lets us rely on that statement in good faith? Hope and faith aren’t enough. You can’t prove securities fraud if all you can show is that you had hope and faith that the facially absurd statement was true. And given law enforcement in recent years, including this mortgage deal, the idea that something much bigger, much better is around the corner is facially absurd.
I’ll say this: journalists and organizers can and must do a better job of fully informing the electorate, empowering everyone to speak with a coherent voice on these issues. But the AGs’ commitment and loyalty can’t be contingent on grass roots action. I know the FDR quote. But I also know our soldiers don’t say, Hey, you want me to do the right thing? Go ahead and make me do it. Why should we have to make you do the right thing? The analogy between you and soldiers may not be apt, but it’s a lot more apt than you as Presidents.
At least that’s how I see it. And I want to say: Based on the public record, not inside intel (I don’t have any) I think Biden would’ve held out if even one other state had stood with him.
Sincerely,
Abigail Caplovitz Field







19 Comments
Shawnna on February 28, 2012 at 1:43 am.
Thank YOU Ms. Field for continuing to stand up and point out the truth.
With you and others like you – Martin Mandelman comes to mind – we’d all be hard pressed to get the truth about what is happening right before our eyes.
At 58 years old, I’m deeply ashamed at what has become of the country I love dearly.
But that doesn’t mean I’m giving in. I’m going to fight for my own home and help others fight for theirs. Knowledge is power and we need everyone to know about the fraud – and more importantly – how to fight it.
Katheryn on February 28, 2012 at 9:48 am.
Abigail,
We need more media people like you who are willing to stand up and shout the truth about the too big to fail banks. We all thank you for the hard work and effort you give to the cause, but we still need so much more. We need to publically hammer the truth to all of the 99% whether or not they ‘think’ or ‘believe’ they have not be affected. The value of mostly everyones property has been decimated by these white collar hoodlums as well as a yet undetermined amount of tax dollars that have been siphoned by them as well. The unaccounted for tax dollars as well as the criminal ponzi scheme must be pounded into the general populations head so that they really “get it”. Please stress this to each of your media friends and associates to really keep this in the public eye. Do public stories on the relationships between the agencies, ie: Fannie Mae MuniMae, MRC/MMA and Blackrock. All of these inner connections are the same as insider trading. The connection between these companies and Fannie Mae as a quasi governmental organization that played a large part in loans that would fail. The press has the ability to trace these connections and out them to the public. More pressure on courts to rule by the law not by personal biases. The word needs to be put in front of peoples faces. If they think something has no bearing on their own personal lives at any given time, they don’t concern themselves with it. Everyone needs to hear and know the truth.
Pingback: The State Attorneys General, Yes, They Sold Us ALL Out…… | Matt Weidner - Fighting For The American People
Pingback: What I’m Reading
Deby on February 28, 2012 at 12:01 pm.
Keep on tracking Abigail – if those in power can’t take the journalistic heat they need to get out of the nation’s kitchen; I would be morally appalled to state I was part of today’s political arena – they lack balls and strength – perhaps we need a major collapse in our country to remind those in power what it means to stand together, to look out for one another – maybe we are headed for a 2nd civil war in this country – people v bankers – eventually the AGs, etc., are going to have to take a side or get out because at the end of the day it is us humans who vote them in – or out. I can assure you when it comes down to looking out for one another or a bankster – the bread will be shared with the people but the bankster will be asked to piss off; go eat its securities and worthless paper – we need to pull the plug on these entities with a DNR – otherwise they are taking the vital oxygen we need to survive with their criminal conduct; isn’t that a form of murder to deprive a living being oxygen to survive whether it be a breath of life or shelter? Either way, the threats on living beings should never be tolerated by those in power – someday it may be their own breath – who will intervene for them if we’re all gone?
flex on February 28, 2012 at 1:18 pm.
America,
Read this article and share it with millions of people all over the country and the world. It is time we get inform, involve, and educated about what really matters today. So go ahead and dive in reading and sharing the knowledge. If this AG’s deal goes through, we are so screwed again. This is another bail out for the banks under the mask of a good deed and just for someone to get re-elected. What had President Obama done for you lately about Foreclosure? He does not even talk about it. The 3 candidates showing on the polls are nothing but puppets and clowns. They cannot even talk about the real issues we are facing today. The whole system is a joke. The FBI, the FTC, the FCC, the DOJ, is all manipulated by a President that cannot even be a real President and take care of the people. Instead he sides with the banksters and in the near future the banksters will become your landlord. How do you like that? For a while I thought the government was going to be the landlord. I was wrong when I found out that the government will use their buddies Goldman Sachs and others to entertain the deal of 1.8 million homes given to the government from Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac from all the illegal foreclosures they did for the last few years.
If the majority of us don’t give a darn, they will go on with their lives like nothing is happening and it is not their problem. The sad part is, they soon will face the same fate like everybody else. By the time they will realize what happened, it will be too late. Imagine another 4 years with Obama. Or imagine 4 years with Mitt Romney. What a disaster that will be?
What else can we do? Pray, pray to God to do something about it. Because we sure don’t know what to do, right?
How long are we going to take this madness? When America is going to wake up and speak up and go out by the millions and protest that we are not going to take it anymore? The few thousands out there with the OWS movement are not enough to get their attention. They get arrested in a couple of hours and the law enforcement pretends they are doing a great service for the rest of us. They are in the same boat like us. They have to pay mortgage and feed their kids and take care of their families. They also get to lose their homes in foreclosure. Their homes are also upside down or underwater. Please somebody show me a judge, an attorney, a doctor, a police officer, or a veteran who is not losing their home in foreclosure. The banks don’t discriminate who they are going to foreclose. They will foreclose anyone since they only go by the loan that is just a number for them.
mark on February 28, 2012 at 7:46 pm.
We are witnessing the greatest heist in history. In our brief filed last Thursday in the Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. v. Jones NJ foreclosure case we attempted to give the trial judge a sense of what’s at stake in every individual foreclosure case. Below are two excerpts.
Dear Judge Jacobson:
Please accept this letter brief of Defendant Gustina Jones in opposition to a motion for a confidentiality order submitted on behalf of witnesses Francis Hallinan, Esq. (“Hallinan”) and Full Spectrum Legal Services, Inc. (“Full Spectrum”) representative witness Jay Mullen (“Mullen”). Full Spectrum is the mortgage foreclosure servicing business owned by the Phelan, Hallinan & Schmieg P.C. named partners. Defendant Jones has also filed a cross-motion to compel Hallinan to answer questions he refused to answer in his deposition. These motions are returnable on March 2, 2012.
Preliminary Statement
“Among the fundamental principles of any functioning justice system is the following: Don’t lie to a judge or falsify documents submitted to a court, or you will go to jail. Breaking an oath to tell the truth is perjury, and lying in official documents is both perjury and fraud. These are serious criminal offenses, but apparently not if you are at the heart of America’s financial system. On the contrary, key individuals there appear to be well compensated for their crimes.”*
[*“Too Big to Jail,” by Simon Johnson, February 22, 2012. http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/johnson29/English Mr. Johnson is a former International Monetary Fund Chief Economist & is currently a professor at MIT Sloan School of Management.]
For many years a state of lawlessness has prevailed in that part of the New Jersey court system responsible for handling residential mortgage foreclosures. The tip of the iceberg has been the systemic use of knowingly false affidavits and mortgage assignments to speed the eviction of New Jersey homeowners from their residences. The submerged portion of the iceberg conceals the widespread theft of monies from homeowners, including Defendant Gustina Jones, as well as from investors, insurers and taxpayers. These thefts have been going on for years and have been and still are being committed by a handful of mortgage banking institutions, including Defendant Countrywide Home Loans, Inc.
Ms. Jones’ case is but one of many millions of foreclosures nationwide based on fraudulent MERS ownership claims in which plaintiff mortgage banking institutions have participated and reaped illicit profits from predatory mortgage servicing. Ms. Jones’ case is a DNA strand found at the scene of a financial crime. If one unravels the DNA strand, one breaks the code to solving a much wider, long-standing financial crime of historic proportions.
The evidence shows that Ms. Jones is the victim of a predatory lending enterprise that intentionally engages in unconscionable servicing practices and makes fraudulent insurance claims to reap further profits for the enterprise. At the end of the foreclosure process only a small amount of money will have been stolen from Ms. Jones. A much larger amount is stolen from investors, insurance claims and ultimately the taxpayers, all whom have a direct financial interest in Ms. Jones’ loan. Aggregated the frauds amount to hundreds of billions, if not trillions, of dollars.
In an effort to thwart the public’s right to know and impede Ms. Jones’ ability to communicate effectively and share relevant information with counsel representing other homeowners facing similar unconscionable practices, counsel for Hallinan and Full Spectrum seeks a blanket protective order as to the depositions of Hallinan and Full Spectrum and the documents produced in those depositions pursuant to Ms. Jones’ discovery subpoenas. The basis for this extraordinary relief is a wholly unsubstantiated attack on the integrity and motives of Defendant Jones’ counsel, James F. Villere and Mark J. Malone. The vitriol directed at them is best understood by an exposition of how Plaintiff Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. and its agent, Phelan, Hallinan and Schmieg, P.C., have fabricated an ownership claim to Ms. Jones promissory note and mortgage and exploited that claim through a pattern of unconscionable billings that illegally inflate the amount due by Ms. Jones on her mortgage obligation and unfairly burden her right to try to save her home. These wrongs are not an isolated events or the result of mistake. Instead they are part of a common plan engaged in by Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. and its related businesses and agents to deliberately steal money from Ms. Jones and other victims.
* * *
The June 13, 2007 bailment letter provides a clue into the labyrinth of fraudulent transactions through which the Jones mortgage loan has traveled. The letter discusses a number of promissory notes that comprise a portion of the collateral “held by Colonial Bank, N.A., pursuant to the Mortgage Warehouse Loan and Security Agreement dated as of April 5, 2004 between Security Atlantic Mortgage Co., Inc. and Lender.” The bailment letter provided that if the notes were not purchased by Countrywide Home Loans, they were to be returned to Colonial Bank, N.A. A MERS Milestones report provided by Plaintiff in discovery suggests that Countrywide never purchased the notes pursuant to the bailment letter’s terms.
MERS Milestones reports allegedly track transfers of interests in mortgage loans among MERS members. If accurate, the MERS Milestones report provided in discovery tells a tale of ownership transfers that directly conflicts with the ownership claims set forth in Plaintiff’s complaint, the MERS assignment of Ms. Jones’s note and mortgage fabricated by Hallinan and Strain, and Countrywide’s alternative bailment letter claim. In chronological order, the MERS Milestones report recounts.
1. June 11, 2007. Jones loan registered on the MERS System showing Security Atlantic Mortgage Co., Inc. as the servicer.
2. June 21, 2007. New servicer listed as BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP. (This was at a time when BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP did not exist.[1])
3. June 21, 2007. New investor listed as BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP. (In addition to the fact that BAC Home Loans Servicing did not exist in 2007, this investor status conflicts with an April 7, 2011 certification of Bank of America, N.A. employee Bridget Lett submitted in In the Matter of Residential Mortgage Foreclosure Pleadings and Document Irregularities, Docket No. F-59553-10 stating that BAC Home Loans Servicing, LP acted as only a servicer for others who owned the loans.)[2]
4. August 15, 2007. Initiating Organization/User listed as Government National Mortgage Association and “Old Interim Funder” listed as “FDIC as Receiver for Colonial Bank, effective 8/14/09.” (Remarkably, this entry accurately predicts that 2 years later, in 2009, the FDIC will take over Colonial Bank as its receiver.)[3]
5. August 15, 2007. New investor listed as Government National Mortgage Association. (Ms. Jones purchased Federal Housing Agency (“FHA”) insurance in connection with her loans.[4] Ginnie Mae’s website reports that Ginnie Mae securitizes 99.5% of all FHA insured loans.[5] A Referral Account Detail Report, the document by which Plaintiff allegedly referred the foreclosure matter to Hallinan’s firm, contains the following information that appears to relate to a Ginnie Mae securitization of Ms. Jones loan: GII FX G-F – 6BPS.[6]
[1] BAC Home Loans Servicing LP, a Texas limited partnership, came into existence in April 2009. February 23, 2012 Villere Certification, ¶ 14 and Exhibit 6.
[2] “As the loan servicer, BAC Servicing acts on behalf of a mortgagee, but it is not the mortgagee itself.” ¶ 1, Lett Certification. A copy of the April 7, 2011 Bridget Lett certification is attached to the February 23, 2012 Villere Certification, ¶ 19 and Exhibit 11.
[3] February 23, 2012 Villere Certification, ¶ 20.
[4] At the closing of her loan, Ms. Jones purchased FHA mortgage insurance paying $3675. A copy of the HUD 1 statement is attached to the February 23, 2012 Villere Certification, ¶ 21 and Exhibit 12 (CHL(GJ)216-217). Thereafter, Ms. Jones paid $97.80 per month as a premium for the insurance. February 23, 2012 Villere Certification, ¶ 22 and Exhibit 13 (May 4, 2011 QWR response, ¶13).
[5] http://www.ginniemae.gov/media/ginnieFAQ.asp?Section=Media
“In effect, Ginnie Mae serves as the banker for FHA, VA, and other government mortgage insurers. The capital used to finance government insured and guaranteed mortgage loans is raised through Ginnie Mae MBS. FHA and other government agencies insure or guarantee the lender in case of a borrower default, while Ginnie Mae guarantees the investor in case of a lender default.
Lenders originate the FHA, VA, or PIH mortgage loans and package them into MBS, which are then guaranteed by Ginnie Mae. Ginnie Mae securitizes more than 99.5 percent of FHA mortgages and 97 percent of VA mortgages.
Since Ginnie Mae is a wholly-owned government corporation within HUD, the President of Ginnie Mae and the FHA Commissioner both report to the Secretary of HUD.”
[6] A copy of the Referral Account Detail Report is attached to the February 23, 2012 Villere Certification, ¶ 23.
* * *
Since taxpayers and pension funds are the most significant groups of victims in terms of footing the bill for the mortgage bankers’ thefts, we have got to figure a way to engage them.
Mark
Todd W on July 31, 2012 at 4:24 pm.
Mark- please contact to share resources. We are litigating all over and your post on Hallinan ducking depo questions caught my eye. I’m “lucky” enough to have gotten f/c mill attorney Thomas P. Dore under oath in Balto. Co. Circuit Court in 11 Aug 2010 hearing to admit he has no first hand knowledge, cannot authenticate any documents, has no credibility and is not the document custodian, while at the same time attempting to pass off a color copy of a purported “original” note into evidence.
Go figure that ever since that hearing, the Balto Co. Circuit Court has obstructed me from getting me and my mouth back into court. Had to resort to interlocutory appeals, Mandamus to force crooks to schedule a hearing will do Petitions for Writ of Cert to Supreme Court if necessary.
Decided to get them out of their element by using Petition for Pre-Suit Discovery per NY CPLR 3102 filed in Brooklyn (Judge Shack’s backyard) and cowards tried to remove to federal court and hired one of the oldest law firms in Manhattan to deal with “little ole me”.
Will gladly share everything we are doing, resources etc. Discovery wins the day 100% of the time. You MUST get discovery and they don’t want you to get that discover since the entire house of cards will collapse.
Email me direct -todd@surefirehomeretention.com. Your post is excellent. Hitting the weak links- crooked fraudclosure attorneys and “affiants” is one of best ways to bring them to their knees.
Hang tough and keep hammering them into submission. Things are turning but everyone needs to take the fight to them.
Pingback: Dear State Attorneys General: You Failed America. Yes, You.
Yata on February 28, 2012 at 11:58 pm.
Its a sad comment on the state of our elected officials when they can generate no better strategy than to follow the wishes of the financial sector.
I have the sense that this “best deal negotiated” will in turn screw just that many more people and expose, time again, the financial sector and their government puppets for the sham that they are.
Abigail, you’ve done an outstanding job keeping us readers current and informed in the secret and disgusting world of compunctionless financial actors, and feckless salaried regulators. You are absolutely loved. Thank you
Tom on February 29, 2012 at 1:38 pm.
Spot on…thank you for standing up and screaming this out. We need the rest of America to understand wtf is going on here. Too many people have their heads buried in the sand and other dark places and refuse to understand.
When did “We the people…” decide to turn a blind eye to what is effecting each and every one of us. If the common man doesn’t think it has effected him/her, they need to understand the hidden cost of all of this on each and every person that consumes ANYTHING in this country.
Abi – keep it coming!
Cheers,
Tom
David on March 2, 2012 at 9:17 am.
Please keep it going, Abigail Field. Continue to spread the knowledge. Go on Dylan Ratigan’s show and others. You are one of a few brave, lone voices representing many thousands who feel that they have no champion.
It has been said that if you don’t feel that you care enough– it may in fact be a shield against caring too much… (possibly by a fictional character in an Ayn Rand novel). What I and others threatened by foreclosure may feel is numbness, powerlessness, a creeping realization that no matter how much we care– after all, our houses, our livelihoods, our very lives as we know them are threatened– nothing that we can do is having the effect of turning the tide…
Local newspaper classified ads are full notices of new foreclosures daily, evidence of the waves continuing to sweep over us. Very infrequently, you hear about an exception– where a judge sides against a bank and in favor of a homeowner. So, we are hardened against the bad news we keep hearing. We are tired by our fight. We hunger for a change of tone: that there is the possibility of winning, that the law is found to be on our side…
Pingback: 15MOF “Whistleblowers Prevail – State Attorneys General Fail” | wgrnradio.com
Pingback: 15 Minutes Of Fact: “Whistleblowers Prevail – State Attorneys General Fail” | Fifteen Minutes of Fact
DL Clementson on March 20, 2012 at 10:16 am.
Nobody is listening and I don’t know how many times I have to say this before someone, somewhere picks it up and puts it out there in the mainstream media for the world to see.
The United States Government, let me rephrase that, from the U.S. Government right on down to our local governments and our local court systems there exists a conspiratory effort to keep the general public distracted by one investigation (charade would be a better word) after the next by one or more government entities, this includes the BS we all witnessed in the forming of the federal consumer protection bureau that has turned out to be another toothless entity sitting along side all the other toothless money pits created by the selfserving elected officials hangin out in WDC. That would be the District of “We Don’t Care”>
Anyhow, the reason behind these distractions is a little thing called the Statute of Limitations as they apply to the common man, that would be you and me. By the end of this year any crime, civil or criminal, that you might feel was directed at you by the TBTF Banksters will no longer be prosecutable because time has run out.
While the little guy sits in front of his computer waiting for the latest development of this government action or this law suit or that consent decree, the clock is ticking. Tick, Tock……
If you’ve been harmed then get out from infront of that screen and file an action, even a small claims action, anything before it’s too late.
With the exception of just a handful of Attorneys General the rest of the lot should be removed from office for failing their oath to the people who elected them [deleted rest of sentence b/c suggested violence is the answer]
Good luck out there..
TheGrey
Abigail Caplovitz Field on March 20, 2012 at 10:37 am.
I reject violence and will delete comments/sections of comments that advocate it.
Heidi Cooper on March 1, 2013 at 6:47 am.
Dear Ms. Field, 3/1/13
I’m writing to wonder if you’d have interest in being included as consulting counsel in a class action pursuit regarding the unconstitutionality of The National Mortgage Servicers’ Settlement Agreement (NMS)?
I’m a harmed borrower and read the Consent Judgment in December 2012, deducing I had substantial standing to pursue enforcement action against Citi for 10 original violations, 5 repeated, mostly Exhibit A and E specific. As an authorized donee, I have right-of-action to enforce the contract, and I chose penalty amounts for violations identical to those listed in Exhibit E for servicers, since, I reasoned, I’m an equal party, equal to the same stated remedies. From this formula, statutory + compensatory (general), I’m at 66M, plus 73 FDCPA violations. I’d believed, as most will, that each specific mandate violation constituted a violation penalty. I could prove the violations and I thought this would be undisputable and condemning.
I’d saved your Huffington Post article regarding Exhibit E-1, to my favorites file last year, before I’d read the contract, and since your article referred to items I had no access to at the time, I didn’t quite understand it’s shocking impact. I rediscovered it Wednesday, it’s greatly influenced and changed the direction of my complaint, widening my Defendant’s list to include all Promisee and Promisor signatories. They each are complicit by being negotiating parties, of either contributing and/or knowing all details of the contract, and the intentional and significant harm to be inflicted on an unaware, intended third-party.
Borrowers who may have read the contract, a group I imagine to be relatively small, probably also skipped over Exhibit E-1, not knowing the basis for the various ‘if P then Q’ variables. Borrowers who were told of the many NMS benefits by way of a federally-sponsored website, were encouraged and directed by federal representatives to seek new, improved mortgage solutions with their servicer, based on these mandated, reforming mortgage-servicing behaviors. None of us signed a consent agreement to be exposed to and significantly harmed by the many, non-disclosed detrimental benefits that will be used against us in the loan modification/loss mitigation processes and beyond.
We’ve been tricked into utilizing a flawed-at-inception mortgage product, provided to us by the Promisee, who had fiducial duty to act in our best interest and on our behalf in contract negotiations. As members of a national class of residential mortgage loan borrowers, we’ve been deceived by our government, of whom we’ve detrimentally relied, and massive fraud is currently being conducted against the American people. This toxic mortgage product needs to be immediately halted, significantly reformed, if it is to be continued at all. This is just as egregious as if the government intentionally exposed it’s population to nerve gas, and I’m in deep disbelief that mortgage borrowers’ priorities have been so cruelly sacrificed as a negotiating tool.
My complaint is being reviewed by a Philadelphia Class Action firm, and I should hear of their representative decision next week. I’ve shared your HF article about Exhibit E-1 with them to further develop their understanding of fact.
Thanks,
Heidi Cooper
Atlanta
404-857-7796
Pingback: Obama’s Big Lie « Reality Check
Pingback: 15 Minutes Of Fact: “Whistleblowers Prevail – State Attorneys General Fail” | Al Cole Radio Network